A Brief Treatise on Beer Flavor

Copyright © 1995

Reading the section on brewing first will enhance your understanding of this section. Click here for "A Brief Treatise on Brewing."

Many things contribute to the flavor, aroma, "mouth feel," and appearance of beer. The way that various brewing ingredients and techniques affect these characteristics are discussed here.

Water
Malt
Specialty Malts
Hops
Yeast
Flavorings


Water

The major ingredient in beer, water is the least significant. Water varies with location as to what is dissolved in it. Organics, dissolved gases, and inorganics are three broad categories. Volatile organics and gases (such as the chlorine used in sanitizing municipal water supplies) are driven off when the wort is boiled. Unless they occur in unusually high concentration, the salts in water used for brewing do not have a discernible taste in the final beer. Acidic or basic inorganics in water, of course, affect the pH. Brewers doing mashing must pay attention to this and adjust it if necessary. Incidentally, some minerals are desirable, as they provide nutrients needed by the yeast.

Malt

Malt is the oldest and most important ingredient in beer. Without malt, there would be nothing to ferment! Ancient beers were created with only two known ingredients: water, and malt or some other source of fermentable sugar (such as honey, which is used in mead). Wild yeast was responsible for the fermentation.

Malted barley is the standard beer grain, but wheat, corn, rice, oats, and other grains are mashed along with at least some barley (which contains the enzymes necessary for breaking down the starches into fermentable sugars) in many beers. These grains, as well as sugars such as sucrose and dextrose, can be used as adjuncts. Used in place of malted barley, they will give the beer a lighter body.

The amount of malt extract in the wort affects the color: small amounts of malt yield a light-colored beer; a large amount of light malt or a lesser amount of amber malt with yield an amber (and perhaps red-hued) beer; and a lot of any malt, but especially a dark malt, will yield a dark beer. The color is also deepened by the addition of specialty malts near the end of the boil.

The more fermentable sugars from the malt there are present in the wort, the more available to be fermented into alcohol. Provided that nothing kills the yeast (such as the alcohol concentration getting above about 9% by volume), all fermentable sugars will be converted into alcohol.

The other carbohydrates present will not be fermented, but will give the beer body and color. Higher-order sugars from the malt, and certain intentionally added sugars, such as lactose, are not fermentable by brewing yeasts and will cause a sweetness in the final beer. The concentration of these larger sugar molecules can be increased by mashing appropriately, as well as by simply putting more malt in the wort. Dextrins, on the other hand, do not cause a sweet taste, but give the beer a slightly more viscous (less watery) "mouth feel." The concentration of dextrins can also be controlled during mashing, as well as by the addition of specialty malts.

Here arises a point about the relationship between beer color and alcoholic strength. Popular belief holds that darker beers are stronger. There is a correlation, but if the malt was dark to start with, or if specialty malts made the wort darker, a dark beer would have the same strength as a light-colored beer that started with the same concentration of fermentable sugars.

Specialty Malts

Most specialty malts start as malted barley, which is roasted to various degrees, resulting in darker colors ranging to black. The darkest of these, black patent malt, primarily adds color to the beer. "Chocolate" malt is roasted less, and will give the beer a chocolate-coffee flavor, as well darkening it. These malts are not mashed and do not contribute fermentable sugars to the wort. "Crystal" malt, on the other hand, is partially mashed in the kernel, and will add fermentable and unfermentable carbohydrates. The unfermentable higher sugars and dextrins are important in adding to the sweetness and less-watery mouth feel of the final beer.
These whole barley kernels are crushed and steeped in warm wort, after which the husks are removed. An alternative method is adding near the end of the boil. Adding during the boil is a common practice, but the husks can add tannins and other chemicals that lend a harsh bitterness (different from the hop bitterness) to the beer.

Hops

Hops were originally added to beer as a preservative. During fermentation there are many carbohydrates in the wort that bacteria could thrive on. Bacterial infections give a nasty taste to beer and are obviously undesirable. The acids released by the hops kill most such bacteria. The hop acids continue to protect the unfermentable (by yeast) sugars from being digested by bacteria that may have gotten into the finished beer.

In modern times, the most important functions of hops are to give a bitterness that balances the sweetness of the malt and to provide a "hoppy" aroma, especially noticeable in highly hopped beers such as India pale ales.

Hops varieties vary in bitterness, containing from 4 to 13% alpha acid. More hops in the wort results in more bitterness, as does boiling for longer in a more dilute wort (this is referred to as "hop utilization rate"). Hops strains also vary in aroma. This is harder to quantify, but again, more hops added late in the boil yield more hoppiness.

Yeast

Yeast is a single-celled fungus. There are many, many strains of yeast, such as baker's yeasts, brewer's yeasts, wine and champagne yeasts, wild yeasts, and yeasts found in infections in humans. Brewing yeasts are broadly divided into lager and ale yeasts. Lager yeasts are intended to give a clean taste to the beer, while ale yeasts leave their mark by synthesizing organic chemicals other than ethanol. Various esters are probably the most noticable across the realm of ales, resulting an "ale taste," as well as more-easily-described flavors of apple, banana, and pineapple. The strain of yeast traditionally used in wheat beers produces some 4-vinyl guaicaol, which gives a clove character to the beer. Combinations of yeast strain, starting sugars, and higher-than-standard temperature can be responsible for chemicals causing other flavors, such as a cidery taste or a butterscotch flavor.

Flavorings

In addition to the traditional ingredients, flavorings are sometimes used in beer. Most of them can be placed into two groups, spices and fruits.

Spices are traditionally used in some countries in special beers at Christmastime. Popular spices are clove, ginger, nutmeg, cinnamon, cardamom, and orange peel. These beers tend to be heavier ales, with the spices substituting for some of the hopping.

Fruit flavor can be added as whole fruit (usually crushed to yield more juice) or as extract, which is simpler. In addition to flavor, fruits add sugar, which results in a slightly stronger beer, but does not contribute much to body. Probably the most frequently used fruit in beer is cherries (as exemplified by the the kriek lambics of Belgium). Other popular fruits are raspberries, blackberries, marion berries, apricots, and passion fruit. Vegetables are sometimes also used, notably peppers for spicy beers and pumpkin for Halloween/Thanksgiving beers.